Socrates on writing

socrates on writing For instance: the relative value of the spoken and the written word since i happen to write words for a living, i spend quite a bit of time pondering this, as you might imagine socrates never wrote a single word he did not believe in it why waste your time killing words (since to write them down was, to him,.

Previously, i shared a curmudgeonly 1889 article about the menace of electricity and the telephone and its spiritual cousin, a fifteenth-century screed lamenting the printing press i'm collecting data here in service of a hypothesis that progress is universally despised, that the “get off my lawn you. The greek philosopher socrates once told a story about the egyptian god theuth and the king ammon theuth had invented the technology of writing and explained to the king how his new invention would make egyptians wiser and improve their memories ammon didn't agree he could just as easily. Plato on writing socrates [to phaedrus]: the story is that in the region of naucratis in egypt there dwelt one of the old gods of the country, the god to whom the bird called ibis is sacred, his own name being theuth he it was that invented number and calculation, geometry and astronomy, not to speak of draughts and dice,. I hadn't expected socrates to appear in a book titled, personal connections in the digital age but there he was, on page 25 the author, nancy baym, was quoting one of his famous dialogs in the phaedrus, from about 370 bc he was telling a story about the invention of writing, and i was surprised at. Discover socrates quotes about writing share with friends create amazing picture quotes from socrates quotations. The spoken and the written word by william chase greene in a famous passage of the phaedrus (274c-277a), socrates is represented as being suspicious of the art of writing though it is supposed to be a help to the memory, actually it leads to forgetful- ness, since it encourages one to rely on written. Soon after socrates' death, several members of his circle preserved and praised his memory by writing works that represent him in his most characteristic activity —conversation his interlocutors in these (typically adversarial) exchanges included people he happened to meet, devoted followers, prominent.

socrates on writing For instance: the relative value of the spoken and the written word since i happen to write words for a living, i spend quite a bit of time pondering this, as you might imagine socrates never wrote a single word he did not believe in it why waste your time killing words (since to write them down was, to him,.

The philosopher socrates remains, as he was in his lifetime (469–399 bce), an enigma, an inscrutable individual who, despite having written nothing, is considered one of the handful of philosophers who forever changed how philosophy itself was to be conceived all our information about him is. [headnote: in reading this excerpt from the phaedrus which reports a dialogue between socrates and phaedrus, crucial to your understanding of what bothers socrates about writing is knowing a bit about his history and his own philosophical method socrates himself never wrote anything all his ideas were written down. In a nutshell, nobody knows for sure we can make educated guesses, based on what we believe about the culture and customs of ancient greece socrates' students. Dr wolf goes back to look at socrates' objections to writing he worried that reliance on writing would erode memory (it has), but also, and maybe more importantly, that reading would mislead students to think that they had knowledge , when they only had data in the dialog titled phaedrus, socrates tells.

In the phaedrus offsite link , written circa 370 bce, plato offsite link recorded socrates's discussion of the egyptian myth of the creation of writing in the process socrates faulted writing for weakening the necessity and power of memory, and for allowing the pretense of understanding, rather than true understanding. Socrates on the forgetfulness that comes with writing socrates (469-399 bce) was a greek philosopher who thought and taught through argumentative dialogue, or dialectic socrates did not write down any of his thoughts, however his dialogues were recorded by his student and protégé, the philosopher plato ( 428 – 347. Phaedrus is so impressed by the arguments of lysias that socrates cannot help but be intrigued socrates asks phaedrus to read the speech and a conversation on the nature of love follows it is only in the very last part of the phaedrus that the discussion on the merits of writing are found as i will argue, the.

In plato's phaedrus, socrates calls into question the propriety and impropriety of writing throughout his discussion with a colleague, socrates insists that writing destroys memory and weakens the mind (ong, 2002) to support his theory, socrates recounts a story in which two egyptian gods, theuth and. Socrates was a classical greek (athenian) philosopher credited as one of the founders of western philosophy, and as being the first moral philosopher, of the western ethical tradition of thought an enigmatic figure, he made no writings, and is known chiefly through the accounts of classical writers writing after his lifetime,. The zeigarnik effect that has been demonstrated many times, in many contexts – but each time i see it or read about it, i can't help but think of an admonition that came centuries before ms zeigarnik sat down to her viennese coffee: socrates' reproach in the phaedrus that the written word is the enemy of.

Socrates on writing

Miami university has an excerpt from the phaedrus, a dialog between socrates and someone named — wait for it — phaedrus, that plato wrote presumably, plato didn't misrepresent socrates' ideas in these dialogs, and socrates did not seem to write anything down: pretty much all we know about his. The classical greek philosopher is credited with laying the foundation of western philosophy – without ever having written a word here, the eminent scholar m m mccabe enters into dialogue with five books to recommend the best texts through which we might understand socrates, and engage with the eternal question.

  • All this reminds me of a famous passage in plato's dialogue phaedrus 274c-277a plato in the mouth of socrates rejects the invention of writing by the same reason that it will end up with memory, essential human faculty the passage contains within itself the greatest of contradictions because plato is a.
  • Of course, it's one of the ultimate ironies that we only know his name and his work because his student plato was the first student to take written notes on the dialogues writing and the greek alphabet were relatively new technologies then i've run across this curious fact about socrates' distrust of text on.

Socrates on technology by jo ellen parker president great lakes colleges association those who believe that technology will cause sweeping transformations in higher education are probably right technology tends to do that the technology of writing and the book, for example, created the modern university higher. In the phaedrus, socrates said that written words “will create forgetfulness in learners' souls, because they will not use their memories they will trust to the external written characters and not remember of themselves” words, he believed , are “an aid not to memory, but reminiscence,” that give people “not. Socrates said writing would destroy human thinking processes: are the internet and web 20 having a more profound effect on cognition, can web 20 really change the way we learn, should textbooks still have value in a 21st century educational system, is the school day on the way out, should there.

socrates on writing For instance: the relative value of the spoken and the written word since i happen to write words for a living, i spend quite a bit of time pondering this, as you might imagine socrates never wrote a single word he did not believe in it why waste your time killing words (since to write them down was, to him,. socrates on writing For instance: the relative value of the spoken and the written word since i happen to write words for a living, i spend quite a bit of time pondering this, as you might imagine socrates never wrote a single word he did not believe in it why waste your time killing words (since to write them down was, to him,. socrates on writing For instance: the relative value of the spoken and the written word since i happen to write words for a living, i spend quite a bit of time pondering this, as you might imagine socrates never wrote a single word he did not believe in it why waste your time killing words (since to write them down was, to him,.
Socrates on writing
Rated 4/5 based on 50 review